Everything to Know for Thanksgiving 2025

Mahalo for considering the Hawaiian Pie Company for your family's Thanksgiving. Thanksgiving is our busiest time of year, so we highly recommend placing your order ahead to ensure you get the pies you love. Whether you order online or by phone, please review the details below — it will help everything go smoothly and ensure we have all the information we need.

-Pie of the Month for November-

(Available baked only)

⚠️ NOTICE ⚠️ - All Thanksgiving Week Orders MUST BE PRE-ORDERED.

There will be no walk-up purchases during Thanksgiving Week (Nov 25-27).

-Special Thanksgiving Dates & Hours-

*CUTOFF for pre-orders may occur sooner if we reach capacity.

We will be closed on Black Friday and Small Business Saturday (the two days after Thanksgiving) to rest and recharge. Normal operations resume on Wednesday, Dec 3rd.

-Thanksgiving Week Pre-Order Menu-

Only the following six pies will be available to pre-order for Thanksgiving Week. Some are available baked and frozen.

• Pumpkin Custard (baked only)
• Caramel Apple
• Hawaiian Passion Pear
• Pear Peach
• Pineapple Whip (baked only)
• Pumpkin

**IMPORTANT** - Be sure to order from the Thanksgiving Pie Menu and NOT the Regular Menu, as not all pies are available to pre-order for Thanksgiving.

-How to Pre-Order for Thanksgiving Week-

• ONLINE - Visit our Thanksgiving menu page, select your pies, choose a pickup day & time, and pay online [CLICK HERE for THANKSGIVING Pre-Order]
• VIA PHONE - Call us during business hours with your order details (pies, quantities, pickup date & time, payment info)
• IN STORE - Place your order in person at the shop

What information do you need if I call in my pre-order?

• Pie flavors (baked or frozen) and quantities
• Pickup date & time
• First & last name
• Contact info (phone & email)
• Credit/debit card for payment or hold

Note: We highly encourage online orders. We’ll do our best to take phone orders, but priority goes to in-shop pickups. Thank you for your understanding.

[ONLINE] Why can't I select a pickup during Thanksgiving Week?

We offer a special menu for Thanksgiving Week. To pick up during that week, you must order from the Thanksgiving Menu.

• Orders to be picked up NOW - Nov 22: Regular Menu
• Orders to be picked up November 25-27: Thanksgiving Menu

Can I pick up on Thanksgiving Day?

Yes! We are open for pre-order pickups only on Thanksgiving Day (Thu, Nov 27) from 8am to 2:30pm.

Can I walk in and purchase pies on Thanksgiving Day?

Unfortunately not. We bake a set number of pies based entirely on pre-orders. Occasionally, some frozen pies not on the Thanksgiving Menu may be available depending on inventory.

Can I pick up my order earlier than scheduled?

Possibly not. We strive to have orders ready on time, but if you arrive too early, we may ask you to return at your scheduled pickup time.

Do I need to order carry-out bags?

Yes. For orders of two or more pies, we highly recommend adding a carryout bag to make pickup easier.

Do I need to pre-pay?

Yes. Payment is required in advance for all Thanksgiving Week orders.

Can I CHANGE, CANCEL, or receive a REFUND?

Changes or cancellations are allowed until the end of business on Saturday, Nov 22. After that, all pre-orders are locked in and all sales are final.

Last day to place a pre-order:

Wednesday, Nov 19 by 11:59pm. Thanksgiving pies may sell out sooner, so don’t wait!

What happens if I don't pick up my order on Thanksgiving?

Any order not picked up on Thanksgiving Day will be re-homed. Missed orders are not eligible for store credit or refund.

-General Info for November-

Full-Size Pies

Pumpkin Custard is our featured pie of the month — a must-try if you love pumpkin or custard pies. Other popular flavors (Caramel Apple, Passion Pear, Pear Peach) are available throughout November. Limited pies not on the Thanksgiving Menu may sell out — frozen options are available to bake at home.

Mini Pies

Mini pies rotate weekly as flavors sell out and restock. For large orders (20+ of one flavor), please order in advance.

Mini Pies & Specials During Thanksgiving Week

No mini pies or specials will be available. Our focus is entirely on full-size pies during Thanksgiving Week.

When should I order?

Now! Pre-ordering is the only way to guarantee your pies for Thanksgiving Week.