Everything to Know for Thanksgiving 2023

Mahalo for considering the Hawaiian Pie Company for your family's Thanksgiving. In anticipation of the busiest pie day/s of the year, we highly recommend ordering ahead of time to ensure you have the pie(s) that you desire. Whether you will be placing your order online through our website or calling us on the phone, please review all the details below before ordering, as it will help you place your order and ensure that we have all the details we need. 


-Pie of the Month for November-

(Available baked only)


⚠️ NOTICE ⚠️ - All Thanksgiving Week Orders MUST BE PRE-ORDERED. 

There will be no walk up purchases during Thanksgiving Week (Nov 21-23).


-Special Thanksgiving Dates & Hours-

DATE What's Going On?
WED, NOV 15th Last Day to Submit a Pre-order*
SAT, NOV 18th Last Day to Cancel a Pre-order

WED - SAT, NOV 15 - 18

OPEN Normal Hours
TUE, NOV 21st Pre-order pickup from 10am to 4pm 
WED, NOV 22nd
Pre-order pickup from 10am to 4pm 

THU, NOV 23rd

Pre-order pickup from 10am to 2:30pm
FRI to WED, Nov 24 - 29 CLOSED
*CUTOFF for pre-orders may occur sooner if we reach capacity.

Please note we will be closed on Black Friday and Small Business Saturday (the two days AFTER Thanksgiving)…because, in full disclosure, we’d like to have a little bit of a rest after the busy Thanksgiving holiday. AND so we can also catch up on all the new streaming shows that have come out! We will resume normal operations on Thursday, November 30th.

-Thanksgiving Week Pre-Order Menu-

Only the following pies listed will be available to pre-order for Thanksgiving Week. Some are available for purchase, both baked and frozen.

  • Pumpkin Custard (baked only)
  • Hawaiian Passion Pear
  • Caramel Apple
  • Pear Peach
  • Apricot
  • Pineapple Whip (baked only)
  • Pumpkin

**IMPORTANT** - When ordering for Thanksgiving Week, be sure you are ordering from the Thanksgiving Pie Menu and NOT our Regular Pie Menu, as not all pies are available to pre-order for Thanksgiving

-How to Pre-Order for Thanksgiving Week-

  • ONLINE - Visit our Thanksgiving menu page, select the pie(s) you'd like to order, select a pick up day & time that works for you, and pay online [CLICK HERE for THANKSGIVING Pre-Order]
  • VIA PHONE - Give us a call when we're open and have your order details handy (pies, quantities, pickup date & time, payment info)
  • IN STORE - Visit us in shop and place your order in person.

What information do you need if I call in my pre-order?

We kindly ask that you provide the following information:

  • Pies that you want (flavor/s, baked/frozen, quantity desired)
  • Pickup Date & Pickup Time
  • Your first and last name
  • Contact information (phone & email)
  • Credit/Debit card to pay for or hold your order

Note: We HIGHLY encourage you to place your order online. We will do our best to take orders over the phone, but we do anticipate a high number of calls, and our priority will be to take care of customers that are picking up at our shop. If you are unable to get through, please consider ordering online. We thank you for your understanding.

[ONLINE] Why can't I select a pickup during Thanksgiving Week?

For holidays such as Thanksgiving, we offer a special menu with specific offerings just for that week. When ordering for Thanksgiving Week, please be sure to order pies from the Thanksgiving Pie menu--otherwise, our website will not offer a pickup during Thanksgiving Week.

While not all pies listed on our regular menu are available to pre-order during Thanksgiving, our more popular pies are listed on both menus. In these cases, you still must order from the respective menu to pickup during specific dates:

  • Orders to be picked up from NOW - November 18: Regular Menu
  • Orders to be picked up from November 21 - 23: Thanksgiving Menu

Can I pick up my pre-order on Thanksgiving Day?

Yes. We will be "open" on Thanksgiving Day for anyone that places a pre-order for pickup on Thursday, November 23.

Can I walk in and purchase pies on Thanksgiving Day?

No. For the safety of our customers and our family, all pies must be pre-ordered for Thanksgiving Week (November 21-23) and picked up at their specified pickup time.

Can I pick up my pre-order earlier than the pickup time I selected?

Possibly not. We do our best to ensure that your order will be ready for pick up a little bit before your scheduled pickup time. However, things can get busy, and if you come too early, we may have to ask that you come back at your scheduled pickup time.

Do I have to order carry out bags for my Thanksgiving order?

Yes. In 2021 the City & County of Honolulu mandated that business offer non-plastic carryout bags for sale to customers. For orders of two pie boxes or more, we HIGHLY recommend ordering a 'Carryout Bag' along with your order to help expedite pickup.

Do I have to pre-pay for my Thanksgiving order?

Yes. Due to the logistical coordination involved and the large number of pies allocated for Thanksgiving, we must ask for payment beforehand.

Can I CHANGE, CANCEL, or receive a REFUND for my order?

Yes! As long as you notify us before the end of business on Saturday, November 18 (the Saturday before Thanksgiving), you can make changes to your order or even cancel your order.

After Saturday, November 18, all customer pre-orders will be locked in, and ALL SALES ARE FINAL (no refunds will be given).

What is the last day that I can place a pre-order for Thanksgiving?

Tentatively the deadline for Thanksgiving pre-orders is:


Should Thanksgiving pies "sell out," we may close Thanksgiving presale BEFORE November 15.

What happens if I don't pick up my order on Thanksgiving Day?

We do our best to follow up with customers who may have forgotten to pick up their orders. However, any order NOT picked up on Thanksgiving, Thursday, November 23, will be placed in a different home for Thanksgiving and will not be eligible for store credit or refund.


-General Info for November-

What FULL SIZE pies will you be offering during November?

Our featured pie of the month is Pumpkin Custard. If you love pumpkin pie or custard pie, you should definitely pick one up! However, our most popular flavors (Passion Pear, Caramel Apple, and Pear Peach) will also be available throughout the month as well. As our menu changes and updates weekly, check with us early in the week for what we’re offering.

As this is a busy time for us, our lower stocked pies or other pies not on our Thanksgiving menu may not be available as they sell out as the month goes on. If you’d like a pie that’s not on our Thanksgiving menu, many of our pies are available to take home frozen to bake at home. We highly encourage you to pick up these pies frozen sooner rather than later.

What MINI pies will you be offering during November?

Our mini-pie menu changes weekly as certain mini pies sell out and different mini pies are restocked. If you’d like to pick up mini pies, please check our menu at the beginning of each week. If you’d like to place a large order of mini pies (20 or more of one flavor), we encourage you to place an order in advance.

Will you be offering MINI PIES or SPECIALS during Thanksgiving Week?


Because of our production schedule and the increased demand during Thanksgiving Week, our sole focus will be on producing as many full-size pies as we can.

Should I order a pie ahead of time or should I pick one up?

For Thanksgiving 2023 you MUST place an order in advance. In an effort to fulfill as many orders as possible, we are unable accommodate walk up sales during Thanksgiving Week.

When should I order my pies for Thanksgiving?

Now! Fortune favors the bold. Good things don’t come to those that wait. We highly encourage you to place an order ahead of time so you can get the pies that you want for Thanksgiving Week.