Best Sellers
Pumpkin Custard Pie
$21.00
Our delectably delicious layered Pumpkin Custard Pie is back. It’s a tasty layer of custard topped with a delicious layer of pumpkin, living in a bed of our melt-in-your-mouth crust,...
Hawaiian Passion Pear Pie®
$25.00
Our most popular pie! We can't remember ... did Grandpa create this magical flavor? Or was it actually Dad (he claims it was him) who invented this in our home...
Caramel Apple Pie
$23.00
Raising the bar on our traditional Apple Pie by mixing in creamy caramel to the filling. This pie has become so popular, it's the only Apple Pie we bake daily...
Pineapple Whip Pie
$25.00
Inspired by our favorite pineapple soft serve! Creamy pineapple filling with pineapple fruit gets topped with a crumble to create pure pineapple bliss. Available BAKED only Contains: Wheat & Dairy...